Knowing when to cut

Tell a position worth saving from one worth closing.

Lesson 6 of 6 in Adjustments · Updated 2026-10-11

Step 1 of 9

You already know a trade ends at its target, its stop, its date, or when the reason for it stops being true. Most positions worth adjusting do not get adjusted. They get closed. Adjusting is for a trade where the reason you took it is STILL TRUE and only the timing has slipped: NIFTY, at 24,018 now, is still heading where you expected, just later. That describes very few of the positions anybody is tempted to rescue.

A firm knows the difference between an order that is late and an order that has been cancelled, and it treats them completely differently. A late order gets managed. A cancelled one gets written off. Treating a cancellation as though it were a delay is how good money goes after bad: in business, and on a screen.

If the reason you took the trade is no longer true, an adjustment keeps the position open without repairing it. An adjustment that leaves you with more risk than before is the position asking for room to be right, which is the same sentence as refusing to accept that it was wrong.

Step 2 of 9

Purpose

This lesson gives one question that decides between adjusting and closing.

  • Most positions worth adjusting get closed instead. The technique is rarely the problem; the choice to use it is.
  • Adjusting is for right-but-early. The reason still holds and only the timing slipped.
  • More risk after an adjustment is a warning, not a repair.
Step 3 of 9

How does it work?

Before touching a losing position, ask in this order:

  • 1. Is the reason I took it still true? If not, close. Nothing is left to adjust towards.
  • 2. If it is, has only the timing slipped? Then an adjustment can buy room.
  • 3. Does the adjustment leave more risk than before? If so, it is a refusal, not a repair.
  • 4. Would I open the adjusted position from nothing? If not, close instead.
Step 4 of 9

Important terms

TermWhat it means
Reason for the tradeWhat you expected to happen when you opened it
Right but earlyThe reason still holds; the move has not come yet
CuttingClosing a losing position and accepting the loss
RescueAn adjustment made to avoid taking a loss rather than to manage risk
Step 5 of 9

Why does it matter?

  • A loss closed early stays small. A loss rescued repeatedly tends to grow.
  • Every adjustment costs money, in charges and in the between buying and selling prices.
  • Clear exits keep the account alive for the trades that do work.
Step 6 of 9

What can change it?

  • News or a broken level can end the reason in a single session.
  • Time left. A reason that needed a week cannot be kept alive on the last day.
  • Your size. More room on a position that is already too big makes it bigger still.
  • Volatility. A sharp change can alter what the trade can still do.
Step 7 of 9

Common misconceptions

  • "Closing at a loss means I failed." Closing when the reason is gone is the plan working.
  • "Any position can be adjusted back to profit." Many cannot, and trying costs money.
  • "Adjusting is more skilful than closing." Usually it is only more expensive.
Step 8 of 9

What are the risks and limitations?

  • You may close just before the market turns. That is the price of any exit.
  • "Still true" can be self-deception. Write the reason down at entry so it can be checked.
  • The question needs honesty, not a formula. No chart can answer it for you.
  • This is education, not advice. It shows how to decide, not what to decide.
Step 9 of 9

Quick recap

  • If the reason is gone, close.
  • Adjust only what is right but early.
  • An adjustment that adds risk is a refusal to take the loss.

This page is the lesson's theory. Its practice on a sample option chain, the quiz and your progress are in the app.

Track your progress, take the quiz and practise in LearnEzy, free

Educational content only: not investment advice. Worked examples use a sample NIFTY option chain, not today's market. You are responsible for your own trading decisions.