Bullish Butterfly
A mildly bullish position that pays its most at one price, for a small net debit.
A BULLISH is a butterfly with its body placed above the market: buy 1 lower- call at 24,000, sell 2 middle-strike calls at 24,100, buy 1 higher-strike call at 24,200, all in the same . Maximum profit occurs if the market expires exactly at the middle strike. Maximum loss is the net paid: ₹595.
Use it when you are mildly bullish and expect the market to rise and then settle near a specific level. It gives a high reward-to-risk ratio. It is better when is high and expected to fall: near the body the position is short volatility.
Maximum Profit occurs at the middle . Maximum Loss = the net . The profit zone is between the two breakevens. Here that is ₹5,905 at 24,100, against ₹595, between 24,009 and 24,191.
Purpose
Pay a small for a view that NIFTY rises to a particular level and settles there. It is a view on a price, not just a direction: the most it pays is at 24,100.
How it works
Three strikes, four calls, one :
- Buy 1 lower- : here 24,000, at ₹184.15.
- Sell 2 middle- calls (the body): here 24,100, at ₹140.55 each.
- Buy 1 higher- : here 24,200, at ₹106.10.
- Net : the two bought calls cost more than the two sold ones pay, so you pay ₹595 for the .
The body sits above the current market, which is what makes it bullish. the body and the same shape is a neutral .
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Body | The middle , where two calls are sold: 24,100 here |
| Wings | The two bought calls either side: 24,000 and 24,200 |
| Net | What the four calls cost together: ₹9.15 a unit |
| Profit zone | The band between the two breakevens: 24,009 and 24,191 |
| Short volatility | A position that gains when falls, as this one does near its body |
The numbers
| The rule | On this board | Per lot | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net | Both wings - (2 x body) | ₹184.15 + ₹106.10 - (2 x ₹140.55) = ₹9.15 | ₹595 |
| Max profit | Wing width - net , at the body | 100 - ₹9.15 = ₹90.85 | ₹5,905 |
| Max loss | The net | ₹9.15 | ₹595 |
| Lower | Lower + net | 24,000 + ₹9.15 = 24,009 | On the index |
| Upper | Higher - net | 24,200 - ₹9.15 = 24,191 | On the index |
Risk to reward is 1 : 9.9: a small against a much larger best case, because the best case needs one exact price.
Worked example
NIFTY at 24,018, 7 days to on Mon 23 Nov, one of 65. Max loss ₹595 · Max profit ₹5,905 · Breakevens 24,009 and 24,191.
| Where it finishes | Altogether |
|---|---|
| At or below 24,000 | -₹595 |
| At 24,050 | +₹2,655 |
| At 24,100, the body | +₹5,905 |
| At 24,150 | +₹2,655 |
| At or above 24,200 | -₹595 |
One peak and two slopes. Too far either way costs the same: being too right is as expensive as being wrong.
When to use it
- You are mildly bullish and expect the market to rise and then settle near a specific level.
- You want a high reward-to-risk ratio and can accept that the full reward needs one price.
- is high and expected to fall. Near the body the position is short volatility, so it gains when volatility drops: entering when it is already low leaves nothing to gain from.
- Conditions where it fits: the market approaching a resistance or a target level, where you expect it to consolidate rather than break out beyond the higher .
- When NOT to use it: you expect a strong rally. At or above 24,200 the whole ₹595 is lost, exactly as if the view had been wrong.
- When NOT to use it: a major event is due before (the Union Budget, an RBI policy decision, a heavyweight's results). A jump past either wing loses the .
Choosing the strikes
| Leg | Preference | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Lower (buy) | or slightly out | Near the current price |
| Middle calls (sell 2) | Higher | 100-300 points above the lower |
| Higher (buy) | Further higher | The same width as lower to middle |
Practical rules
- Place the body above the current market, at the level you expect.
- Keep the wings equal. Unequal wings make it a broken-wing , with a different risk.
- Ideal width: 100 to 300 points, depending on risk appetite.
- A low net relative to the width, on liquid strikes, keeps the reward large against the risk.
What can change it
Where the market goes, the days left, and .
- Time decay helps only near the body. With NIFTY close to 24,100 the two sold calls decay faster than the wings and the position gains. Far from it, time costs you.
- Falling helps near the body; rising volatility hurts. Most of the value only arrives in the last days before .
Market goes up
- Moving towards 24,100 is the profitable path; once much of the maximum is showing, what is left to gain is small next to what a reversal could take back.
- If it rises close to 24,100 with little time left, that is near the maximum-profit zone, and closing there keeps most of it.
- If it runs above 24,200, the loss is the and cannot grow, held or closed.
Market stays sideways
- With the body above the market, a flat market will not reach the maximum.
- Holding or closing early comes down to how much is left.
Market goes down
- Closing takes the loss now; it is already limited to ₹595.
- Roll down if you still expect a later rise: if NIFTY falls to 23,800, close this and open one with its body at 23,900 (buy 23,800, sell two 23,900, buy 24,000).
- Holding adds no risk beyond it: the maximum loss is known.
Common misconceptions
- "It is bullish, so a big rally is good." Above 24,200 the whole is lost.
- "The best case is likely." ₹5,905 needs at exactly 24,100. Most outcomes land somewhere on the slopes.
- "Two sold calls mean open risk above." The bought 24,200 covers the second one.
Risks
- . The two sold calls are margined, but as a complete the requirement is small, close to the ₹595 . Close it as a unit, not a at a time.
- Legging risk. Place all three strikes together. Holding the two sold calls without the higher wing is an open position above.
- Liquidity. Four contracts at three strikes: each extra to cross comes off a small .
- Charges. Four legs of brokerage and taxes against a ₹595 position is a real share of it.
Quick recap
- Buy 24,000, sell two 24,100, buy 24,200: ₹595 at risk, ₹5,905 at most.
- It pays its most at one price, 24,100, and is in profit between 24,009 and 24,191.
- It is short volatility near the body: better entered when volatility is high and expected to fall.