Iron Butterfly
Sell both sides at one strike, and buy back the two open ends.
An IRON sells a and a at the same and buys one of each further out: sell the 24,000 call and put, buy the 24,200 call and the 23,800 put. ₹8,587 arrives up front. It is the short with both open ends closed, and the most it can cost is ₹4,414.
An underwriter who takes premiums on both sides of one risk and then reinsures the extremes of each. The good years pay less than they used to. No year can end the business.
The wings are what you gave up the open for, and they are not optional. A short at 24,000 takes in more and has no number on either end. This takes in ₹8,587 and cannot cost more than ₹4,414, whatever NIFTY does.
Purpose
A view that NIFTY finishes close to 24,000 on Mon 23 Nov, held with a worst case you can write down before placing it.
How it works
Four legs: a sold, and a bought around it.
- Sell the 24,000 and the 24,000 . Both , which is where the is richest. On their own these two are a short .
- Buy the 24,200 and the 23,800 . Four steps out on each side. These are the wings, and they are the only reason this position has a worst case.
- Same , same size, equal wings. 200 points either side here. Unequal wings make the worst case the wider one less the , which is easy to misread on a ticket.
The credit version: the iron butterfly
- Sell the 24,000 and , buy the 24,200 call and the 23,800 put: ₹8,587 taken in, at most ₹4,414 lost.
- Ahead between 23,868 and 24,132. This is the version the rest of the lesson works through.
The debit version: a long call butterfly
- Buy the 23,800 , sell two 24,000 calls, buy the 24,200 call: ₹4,397 at risk, up to ₹8,603 at 24,000.
- The same three strikes and the same tent at , ahead between 23,868 and 24,132. On this board the two worst cases differ by ₹17 a .
- It pays rather than being paid, and blocks less : each sold is covered by a bought wing.
It is the same four- shape an iron condor uses, with the two sold legs pushed together onto one . Everything about how the two behave follows from that.
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Iron | A and a sold at one , with a call bought above and a put bought below |
| Body | The both sold legs share: 24,000 here |
| Wing | A bought four steps out: the 24,200 and the 23,800 |
| Net | What the four legs take in together: ₹8,587 a on this board |
| The body, either side by the : 23,868 and 24,132 |
The numbers
| The rule | On this board | Per lot | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net | Both sold, less both bought | ₹184.15 + ₹136.25 - ₹106.10 - ₹82.20 = ₹132.10 | ₹8,587 |
| Max profit | The , at the exactly | ₹132.10 | ₹8,587 |
| Max loss | One wing's width, less the | 200 points - ₹132.10 = ₹67.90 | ₹4,414 |
| The , either side by the | 23,868 and 24,132 | two of them | |
| Long : max loss | Both wings - (2 x body), the | ₹67.65 | ₹4,397 |
| Long : max profit | One wing - , at the body | ₹132.35 | ₹8,603 |
₹132.10 per unit is both the most it makes and how many points either side of 24,000 it can finish and still be ahead (23,868–24,132). Take in more and the band widens; that is one number doing two jobs, and it is why this structure rewards a rich board.
Worked example
NIFTY with 7 days to , one of 65. Max loss ₹4,414 · Max profit ₹8,587, at 24,000 · Breakevens 23,868 and 24,132.
| Where it finishes | The sold pair | The wings | Altogether |
|---|---|---|---|
| At 24,000 exactly | Both worthless | Both worthless | +₹8,587 |
| Inside 23,868 and 24,132 | One | Worthless | Partly ahead |
| At 24,200 or 23,800 | One | One starting | -₹4,414 |
| Beyond the wings | One | One working | -₹4,414, however far it goes |
The top row needs one price and the second row is where the position actually lives. A learner reading only the maximum will overestimate how often it arrives.
When to use it
A view that it stays , and a board paying enough for saying so.
- You think NIFTY finishes near 24,000. Not merely that it does not trend: that it ends close to where it is now.
- The board is paying well. The is the whole reward and it comes off the premiums in front of you. A quiet board pays less for the same four legs.
- You want the loss to be a number. That is what separates this from the short , and the difference in is the price of it.
- When NOT to use it: a big move is likely, such as before the Union Budget or an RBI policy decision. Past either wing the loss is the full ₹4,414.
- When NOT to use it: your view is a range, not a price. The band that pays is narrow, 23,868 and 24,132; an iron condor gives far more room.
It is the tightest neutral structure here. If the view is "it stays in a range" rather than "it stays here", the iron condor asks for far less precision.
Choosing the strikes
One choice, and it is how much you are paid against how wrong you can afford to be.
- The body goes . 24,000 here. Anywhere else and the structure has a direction in it, which is a different position.
- Narrow wings sit nearer the money and cost more to buy, so the is smaller and the band that pays is narrower, but the worst case is smaller too.
- Wide wings cost less, take in more and give a wider band, in exchange for a larger worst case further away.
- or . The long on the same strikes draws the same tent for ₹4,397. Choose by which quotes are better, and by whether you would rather be paid or pay.
Four legs that all have to be quoted properly. A structure priced off one illiquid wing is a structure whose arithmetic was never real.
What can change it
Two ways to be wrong, and they cost the same.
- It sits near 24,000. Time decay works on all four legs, most on the two sold , and the position walks toward ₹8,587. Most of that value arrives in the last days.
- It moves either way past a wing. ₹4,414, and a further move changes nothing. The structure is closed at both ends.
- It moves and comes back. The most awkward case: the position can be well down and then recover, because the shape is at and the market has not got there yet.
- Volatility rises. The two sold options gain more value than the two wings, so the position shows a loss before even with NIFTY unmoved.
Rolling the untested side toward the money collects more and narrows the band. It is a new position with a new worst case, not a repair.
Common misconceptions
- "The wings give it room." They take part of the , and the credit IS the band, so the band gets narrower: 23,868 and 24,132 against 23,680 and 24,320 for the alone.
- "The maximum is what it usually makes." ₹8,587 needs NIFTY at 24,000 exactly. Most finishes that pay land somewhere inside the band and pay part of it.
- "Defined risk means small risk." ₹4,414 a is a number, not a small one. Knowing it is what lets you size the trade.
- "The long is a different trade." Same strikes, same tent at . The difference is a against a , and the .
Risks
Four things about selling at one .
- . Defined risk means less blocked than for the , which is true and is not the same as less risk per rupee committed. It is easy to place more lots because each one ties up less.
- Four legs is four sets of charges, twice over if it is closed rather than left to expire. Against ₹8,587, that is a real share.
- is worst here at the end. Selling means the position responds hardest to movement in the last days, which is also when the decay is best.
- Liquidity. Each wing is four steps out, where quotes are thinner. If one wing barely trades, every figure built on it is guesswork.
Quick recap
- Sell the 24,000 and , buy the 24,200 call and 23,800 put, for ₹8,587.
- Ahead only between 23,868 and 24,132; the most it can lose is ₹4,414.
- It is a view about one price, and the wings are what turn an open loss into a number.