PCR, and how to not misread it
Use one ratio without letting it make your decision.
The is how many puts are held divided by how many calls are held.
Two people buy the same on the same day, for opposite reasons.
- The first owns a large amount of stock and is buying protection, the way you insure a car you intend to keep.
- The second owns nothing and is speculating that the market falls.
- One is scared and one is hopeful, and the number cannot tell them apart.
- Both push it up by exactly the same amount. The list does not record why anybody bought anything.
- On this board the answer is 1.18, and that is the entire calculation. It does not tell you the market is going up.
Treat 1.18 as a question, not an answer. Ask what changed to move it. On its own it says nothing about how much to risk.
Purpose
- To summarise the whole board in one number, which is the only thing a ratio can honestly do.
- To show what a single figure cannot carry. Two opposite intentions move it the same way.
- To make a reader ask what changed, rather than reading a level off a scale.
How does it work?
- Add up the across every on the board.
- Add up the across every .
- Divide the first by the second: 1.18 on this board.
- That is all of it. There is no weighting, no adjustment, and no record of intent.
What a reading actually says
The conventional readings, and what is wrong with each of them. The right-hand column is the part usually left out.
| Reading | Usually called | What it actually says |
|---|---|---|
| Above 1 | Bullish | More puts are held than calls. Some of them are protection |
| Below 1 | Bearish | More calls are held than puts. Some of them are covered calls |
| Rising | Fear building | Puts were added. Nothing says by whom or why |
| Falling | Confidence | Puts were closed, or calls were added. Two different events |
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| PCR | : 1.18 on this board |
| OI PCR | The version built on . The common one |
| Volume PCR | The version built on today's trading. A different, noisier number |
| Protection | A bought to cover something already owned |
| Contrarian reading | The habit of treating extremes as signals of a turn |
Why does it matter?
- It is the most quoted number in Indian options commentary, so you will meet it whether or not you use it.
- Its change is real information. What moved, and when, is worth knowing even when the level is not.
- It teaches the general lesson about this board: every column is a measurement, and none of them records a reason.
What can change it?
- Hedging season. Institutions buying protection push it up without anybody turning bearish.
- . collapses on the expiring series and the ratio jumps around meaninglessly.
- Which version is being quoted. OI PCR and volume PCR can point different ways on the same day.
- Index versus stock. The typical range is not the same, so a number that is high for one is ordinary for the other.
Common misconceptions
- "High PCR means bullish." It means more puts are held. Whether that is fear or insurance, the number cannot say.
- "It moved, so sentiment changed." If the ratio moved and the price did not, that is people rearranging what they hold.
- "There is a level that means buy." There is no such level, and the ranges differ by instrument and by .
- "It tells me nothing at all." It does tell you what changed. It just cannot tell you why.
What are the limitations?
- It cannot separate protection from speculation, which is its central and permanent flaw.
- It is one number over a whole board, so opposite moves at different strikes cancel out inside it.
- It has no stable scale. What counts as high is a matter of habit, not of arithmetic.
- It is backward-looking. It reports positions that already exist.
Quick recap
- PCR is one division: puts held over calls held. On this board, 1.18.
- Protection and speculation move it identically. That is the whole problem with it.
- The change is information; the level is a habit.
- A ratio that moved while the price did not is people rearranging, not people becoming confident.
- A place to start asking, never a place to stop.