Correlation
Count how many views you are really holding.
Four positions that all need NIFTY to go up are ONE view in four pieces. Not four views. They will lose together, on the same morning, for the same reason, and no amount of careful sizing on each ticket changes that.
A big firm's risk desk does not count how many trades are on. It counts how many DIFFERENT things could go wrong. Positions that need the same thing to happen stack up: what the account actually carries is the four added together, and one bad session acts on that total no matter how many separate confirmations arrived on your phone. Moving one of them to BANKNIFTY, FINNIFTY, MIDCPNIFTY does not fix it either. They all move with the market on the sessions that matter, and not one of them has had a weekly since the 2024 rationalisation, so the same one-week idea quietly becomes a month-long one.
Count the things that could go wrong, not the number of trades. Sizing four tickets sensibly while all four need the same outcome is one large position assembled out of small ones.
Purpose
The lesson on position size set a limit for each trade. This one checks whether several trades are quietly one.
- To count real views, not tickets. Four positions needing the same move are one position.
- To catch the limit being broken without any single trade breaking it.
- To show what actually balances a position: something that needs a different outcome, not just a different .
How does it work?
Worked on a ₹5,00,000 account, with each trade kept inside five percent:
- 1. Each trade looks careful. Five percent is ₹25,000, which covers 2 lots of the 24,000 at ₹11,970 each.
- 2. You open four of them: 2 lots each of the calls at 24,050, 24,100, 24,150 and 24,200.
- 3. All four need the same thing: NIFTY going up before .
- 4. Add them up. 2 lots of each comes to ₹68,907: 13.8% of the account on one view, though no ticket broke five percent.
- 5. One bad session settles all four the same way, on the same morning.
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Correlation | How closely two positions move together. High correlation means they win and lose together |
| One view | A single idea about the market, such as NIFTY rising this week, however many trades express it |
| Concentration | Too much of the account riding on one view |
| Total exposure | All positions that need the same outcome, added together |
| Diversification | Holding things that need different outcomes, so one move cannot settle all of them |
| Offsetting position | A position that gains when the others lose, such as a bought against bought calls |
Why does it matter?
- It breaks your size limit quietly. No ticket is over five percent, yet the account is carrying ₹68,907 on one idea.
- Indian large caps move together. HDFC Bank and Reliance are both large parts of NIFTY, so bullish trades on either one and on NIFTY share the same driver.
- Other indices are not a way out. BANKNIFTY, FINNIFTY, MIDCPNIFTY move with the market on the days that matter, so moving a trade there adds a ticket, not a new view.
- Losses arrive together. The morning NIFTY gaps down is the morning all four lose at once.
What can change it?
How tightly positions move together is not fixed:
- Big news days. On a budget day or a global sell-off, almost everything moves together, whatever it did last week.
- Direction. A bought and a bought on the same index need opposite moves, so they partly offset.
- Different drivers. A view on one company's results is less tied to NIFTY than a second NIFTY trade, but still not free of it.
- Time. Two trades that end on different expiries share a view for only part of their lives.
Common misconceptions
- "Four trades is four times as safe." Four trades on one view is one trade, four times as big.
- "Different strikes means out." Strikes differ; the outcome they need does not.
- "Selling a balances my calls." Selling a is also bullish. It adds a fifth piece to the same view.
- "Another index diversifies me." BANKNIFTY and NIFTY fall together on nearly every day that matters.
What are the risks and limitations?
- Correlation shifts. Positions that moved separately for months can move together on the one day it counts.
- Offsetting costs money. A bought against bullish calls lowers the risk and also lowers what the calls can make.
- Fewer, cleaner positions are not safe either. One position at twenty percent is still twenty percent.
- This is a way of counting, not advice. It tells you what you are carrying, not what to hold.
Quick recap
- Count views, not tickets. Four trades needing the same move are one view.
- Add them up. Four positions at five percent each is twenty percent on one view.
- Other indices move with NIFTY on the days that matter.
- Only something needing a different outcome balances, such as a bought , not a sold one.