The only question that matters
Ask what this can cost before asking what it can make.
The first question about any position is what it can COST you. Not what it can make. One of the 24,000 can take ₹11,970 from you, and that number settles whether this is sensible long before the upside is worth discussing.
A shopkeeper thinking about a big order works out the bad side first. What do the goods cost him. What if nobody buys them. Is the shop still open if that happens. His cut comes second, because a cut on a deal that can close the shop is not a cut worth having.
Work out the worst case before the best case, and refuse to accept anything but a number. Asking in that order also changes which trades look attractive to you, which is the real reason it goes first.
Purpose
This lesson opens the Risk & Discipline track. The Planning a Trade track asked what a trade needs to happen; this one asks what it can do to you if it does not.
- One question comes before the rest: what is the most this position can cost me?
- It turns a trade into a number. One of the 24,000 can cost ₹11,970. That figure can be weighed; "it should go up" cannot.
- It sorts positions into two kinds: those with a worst case you can write down, and those with none.
- It sets up everything after it. Position size, chasing and correlation are all ways of keeping that worst case survivable.
How does it work?
Four steps, done before the order ticket is opened:
- 1. Name what you are doing: buying or selling, a or a , which , how many lots.
- 2. Find the worst case. Bought the 24,000 ? It is the : ₹11,970 for one . Bought the 24,000 ? ₹8,856.
- 3. Check it is a number. A sold with nothing bought above it has no ceiling: every point NIFTY rises above the is another ₹65 per you owe.
- 4. Only then look at the upside, and ask whether it is worth that worst case.
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Worst case | The most a position can lose if everything goes against it |
| Downside | What you stand to lose. The half of the trade to look at first |
| Upside | What you stand to make. The half most people look at first |
| Capped risk | A worst case with a fixed rupee figure, known before you enter |
| Uncapped risk | A worst case with no ceiling: the loss grows as far as the market moves |
| Uncovered sold option | An option sold with nothing bought to limit it. A sold of this kind is uncapped |
Why does it matter?
- The upside cannot hurt you. Only the downside can close an account, so it is the half that needs checking.
- A number can be compared. ₹11,970 is 2.4% of a five lakh account and 23.9% of a fifty thousand one. "Could go up" compares with nothing.
- It changes which trades look good. A ₹184.15 collected by selling looks easy money until you notice its worst case has no figure at all.
- Size depends on it. The lesson on position size starts from exactly this number.
What can change it?
The worst case is fixed by what you hold, so it changes only when the position does:
- Buying versus selling. A buyer's worst case is the paid. A seller of an uncovered has it the other way round: the premium is the most they can make, and the loss is open-ended.
- Adding a . Buying a four strikes up, at 24,200, puts a ceiling on a sold 24,000 call. The worst case becomes the between them less what you took in.
- Lots. Two lots of the 24,000 double the worst case to ₹23,940.
- The . A cheaper further out has a smaller worst case, and a smaller chance of paying anything.
Common misconceptions
- "A sold option is safer because it usually wins." It wins often and small. The loss, when it comes, has no ceiling.
- "My stop loss is my worst case." A stop is a plan. NIFTY can open below it after a weekend, and the order fills where it can.
- "Upside first, then I will think about risk." Once you have pictured the profit, the risk gets rounded down. The order you ask in changes the answer.
- "The worst case never happens." On one trade it rarely does. Across hundreds of trades it becomes likely, sooner or later.
What are the risks and limitations?
- The worst case is not the likely case. Knowing a bought can lose ₹11,970 does not tell you how often it will.
- A capped loss is still a loss. Losing the full , again and again, is how most option buyers end up losing money.
- Uncapped is not the same as certain ruin, but it means no sensible size exists. A sold also blocks cash with the broker, roughly ₹1,87,340 to ₹2,34,176 per , which the lesson on paying and posting explains.
- This lesson does not tell you what to trade. It tells you what to check first. Nothing here is advice to buy or sell anything.
Quick recap
- Ask what it can cost before asking what it can make.
- A bought option's worst case is the : ₹11,970 for one of the 24,000 .
- A sold with nothing above it has no worst case you can write down.
- If it is not a number, you cannot size it, so you cannot decide it.