How wide to make the spread
Choose how far apart to put the strikes, and say what that choice costs.
You have built this structure already and named its three numbers. The question left is how far apart to the strikes. Sell 24,050 against 24,000 and it costs ₹1,495; sell 24,100 instead and it costs ₹2,834. The wider one costs more and can pay more. The narrower one is cheaper and gives up sooner. Nothing else about the structure changes.
A shopkeeper choosing his selling rate is choosing two things at once, and he cannot move them apart. Price it close to what he paid and he sells easily for a thin cut. Price it far above and the cut is fat, on the days anyone pays it. The width of a is that same decision, made once, in advance, and printed on the board as a number.
The width is a statement about how far you think it goes, and you pay for it up front. Widening the raises the ceiling and raises the cost together, so it also raises the level you have to clear before any of it is yours. Pick the you actually expect the move to stop at, not the one that makes the ceiling look biggest.
Purpose
To choose how far apart the two strikes go, knowing that the width sets the cost, the ceiling and the together.
How it works
The bought stays where it is. Only the you sell moves.
- Buy 1 of the 24,000 at ₹184.15, in both versions.
- Narrow: sell 1 of the 24,050 at ₹161.15. Net ₹23.00 per unit.
- Wide: sell 1 of the 24,100 at ₹140.55. Net ₹43.60 per unit.
Both are bull spreads, used here only to show what width does. The full strategy is taught in Bullish Strategies.
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Width | The distance between the bought and the sold one |
| Ceiling | The most the can make: the width less the net |
| The level at where the neither makes nor loses | |
| Net | What the pair costs to open, and the most it can lose |
The numbers
The same three rules on both widths, with this board's prices in.
| The rule | Narrow, 50 points | Wide, 100 points | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net | Bought less sold premium | ₹23.00 (₹1,495 a ) | ₹43.60 (₹2,834 a ) |
| Max loss | The net | ₹1,495 | ₹2,834 |
| Max profit | Width less the net | 50 − 23.00 = ₹27.00, ₹1,755 a | 100 − 43.60 = ₹56.40, ₹3,666 a |
| Bought plus the net | 24,023.00 | 24,043.60 |
Every row moved the same way. A wider costs more, can make more, and needs the market to travel further before any of it is yours.
Worked example
One of 65 of each, held to on Mon 23 Nov.
| Where NIFTY finishes | Narrow (sell 24,050) | Wide (sell 24,100) |
|---|---|---|
| 23,950 | −₹1,495 | −₹2,834 |
| 24,000 | −₹1,495 | −₹2,834 |
| 24,050 | +₹1,755 | +₹416 |
| 24,100 | +₹1,755 | +₹3,666 |
| 24,200 | +₹1,755 | +₹3,666 |
At 24,050 the narrow one is already at its ceiling and the wide one is only part of the way there. Below 24,000 the narrow one loses less. The wide one breaks even at 24,043.60, only beats the narrow one above 24,070.60, and reaches its ceiling at 24,100.
Why it matters
- Width is the one decision left once the direction is chosen, and it fixes the cost, the ceiling and the in one go.
- A wider is not a better spread. It is a view that the move goes further, paid for up front.
- Choosing the width is choosing where you think the move stops. Say that level first, then pick the .
Choosing the strikes
- Buy the where the view starts, usually the one nearest the market.
- Sell the where you expect the move to stop, not the one that makes the ceiling look largest.
- Check the against your target. If the is close to where you think the move ends, the is too wide for the view.
What can change it
- The market moves. A small rise favours the narrow , which reaches its ceiling sooner. A big rise favours the wide one, which has more room to gain.
- Time decay. A wider holds more of the bought 's value uncovered, so it loses more to time if the market sits still.
- changes. Both legs move with volatility and largely offset. The wider the , the less they offset and the more the feels it.
Common misconceptions
- "Wider is always better because the ceiling is higher." The cost and the rose with it.
- "Wider is safer because it covers more strikes." The worst case is what you paid, and a wider costs more.
- "Width changes the direction." It changes how far the view reaches. The direction is set by which side you use.
Risks
- . The sold blocks even with the bought leg covering it. It is small next to an uncovered sale, but it is there.
- Uncovered legs. Close the bought first and the sold has no limit on what it can cost. The two legs open and close together.
- Liquidity. The further out the sold , the thinner its quotes tend to be, and the more of the you give up getting in and out.
- Charges. Two legs, two sets of brokerage and taxes. On a narrow with a small ceiling they take a bigger share.
Quick recap
- Width moves the cost, the ceiling and the together. You cannot raise one without the others.
- Wider needs a bigger move; narrower pays less but reaches its ceiling sooner.
- Pick the sold where you expect the move to stop, then check the against it.