Width, cost and the ratio it forces
Read what a spread demands of you before you take it.
Every prices a chance before you agree to it, and it is not a chance you chose. Buy the 24,000 / 24,100 and you pay ₹43.60 to make at most ₹56.40: one rupee risked to make 1.29, which needs you right 44% of the time. Sell the 24,100 / 24,200 instead and you take ₹34.45 in against ₹65.55 at risk, which needs you right 66% of the time. Neither is the better trade. They are two different questions about how often you are right.
A shopkeeper choosing between a slow-selling item with a fat cut and a fast-selling one with a thin cut is doing this same sum. Neither is better on paper. What decides it is whether the number he actually sells supports the cut he has settled for.
Look at what it can lose against what it can make before you look at the name of the strategy. Then ask honestly how often you are right. Widening from 100 to 200 raises both numbers, and it changes the odds you just agreed to.
Purpose
To read what a risks against what it can make before placing it, because that ratio decides how often you must be right just to break even.
How it works
Two spreads, each with a fixed best case and a fixed worst case. Together they always add up to the width.
- : buy the 24,000 , sell the 24,100 call. Pay ₹43.60 per unit; that is what you risk.
- : sell the 24,100 , buy the 24,200 call. Take in ₹34.45 per unit; that is the most you make.
- The hit rate you need is what you risk divided by the width. That one division is the whole lesson.
These are the bull and the bear call spread, used here only for their odds. They are taught in full in Bullish Strategies and Bearish Strategies.
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Risk-reward ratio | What a trade can make for every rupee it can lose |
| Break-even hit rate | How often it must win, at its best case, to cover its losses at its worst |
| Width | The distance between the strikes: best case plus worst case |
| Max loss / max profit | The two fixed ends of a , known before you place it |
The numbers
The same rules on both spreads, with this board's prices in.
| The rule | Debit 24,000/24,100 | Credit 24,100/24,200 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risked | : what you paid. : width less what you took in | ₹43.60 (₹2,834 a ) | 100 − 34.45 = ₹65.55 (₹4,261 a ) |
| Can make | : width less what you paid. : what you took in | 100 − 43.60 = ₹56.40 (₹3,666 a ) | ₹34.45 (₹2,239 a ) |
| Hit rate needed | Risked ÷ width | 43.60 ÷ 100 = 44% | 65.55 ÷ 100 = 66% |
Neither column is the better trade. One pays more when it wins and wins less often; the other wins more often and pays less each time.
Worked example
One of 65 of each, held to on Mon 23 Nov.
| Where NIFTY finishes | Debit 24,000/24,100 | Credit 24,100/24,200 |
|---|---|---|
| 23,900 | −₹2,834 | +₹2,239 |
| 24,000 | −₹2,834 | +₹2,239 |
| 24,050 | +₹416 | +₹2,239 |
| 24,100 | +₹3,666 | +₹2,239 |
| 24,150 | +₹3,666 | −₹1,011 |
| 24,200 | +₹3,666 | −₹4,261 |
| 24,300 | +₹3,666 | −₹4,261 |
The column wins the same ₹2,239 on every row up to 24,100, and loses up to ₹4,261 above it. That is the 66% at work: the small wins have to pay for each larger loss.
Why it matters
- The ratio is set by the two premiums, not by you. Read it off before you place the trade.
- A trade that wins often is not automatically good. It has to win often enough to cover what it loses.
- Compare the hit rate you need with how often you are honestly right. If you cannot clear it, the trade loses money over time.
Choosing the strikes
- Widening changes the odds. Buy 24,000 and sell 24,200 instead, and you risk ₹78.05 to make ₹121.95: right 39% of the time, but it needs a bigger move.
- Moving a further from the market raises how often it wins and lowers what it pays, so the hit rate it needs rises with it.
- Pick strikes whose hit rate you believe you can beat, not the ones with the most attractive single number.
What can change it
- The market moves. Before the 's value moves within its two ends, and the odds of reaching each end move with it.
- Time decay. It shifts the odds towards the side as days pass without a move, and against the side.
- changes. Higher volatility makes every dearer, which changes the two premiums and so the ratio on offer.
Common misconceptions
- "A high win rate means a good trade." Not if each loss wipes out several wins.
- "The ratio is a matter of taste." It is read off the two premiums on the board.
- " spreads are safer because they win more often." They need to win more often, because each loss is larger.
Risks
- . The blocks against its worst case. Count that cash as committed for the life of the trade.
- Uncovered legs. Closing the bought of either on its own leaves the sold with no limit. The two legs go together.
- Liquidity. Crossing the on two legs shaves the best case and adds to the worst, which worsens the ratio you actually get.
- Charges. Brokerage and taxes on two legs come off every win and add to every loss. On a thin ratio they decide whether it works at all.
Quick recap
- Every prices a chance: what it risks against what it can make.
- Risk over width is the hit rate the trade needs.
- Check that hit rate against how often you are right before you check anything else.