Index funds and ETFs
Know how a beginner can actually own the whole market, and what it costs.
You cannot buy NIFTY itself, but you can buy a fund that copies it. An is a mutual fund that holds the same companies as an index, in the same weights. An , an exchange-traded fund, does the same job but trades on the exchange like a share. Either way, one purchase gives you a small slice of every company in the index.
A thali instead of ordering every dish separately. You get a little of everything on the menu, in the proportions the kitchen decided, for one price. You do not choose the dishes, and that is the point.
- ₹10,000 into a NIFTY 50 buys you a slice of all fifty companies, in the index's own weights.
- : bought from the fund house or through an app, at that day's NAV, the value of one unit, worked out after the market closes. A SIP of ₹500 a month is common.
- : bought through your broker into your account, at live prices during market hours, exactly like a share.
- The yearly cost is small: an expense ratio of roughly 0.05% to 0.3%, against 1% or more for many funds where a manager picks the shares.
- The aim is to match the index, not beat it. The small shortfall is called the tracking difference.
An or lets a beginner own the whole index for a small yearly fee. It will not beat the market, and by design it will not fall far behind it either.
Purpose
- To own the market without picking shares. No research into fifty companies, no guessing which will win.
- To start small. A few hundred rupees buys a slice of every company in the index.
- To keep costs low. Nobody is paid to pick shares, so the fee is a fraction of an actively managed fund's.
How does it work?
- 1. The fund collects money from many investors.
- 2. It buys the companies in the index, in the index's weights.
- 3. When the index changes its members, the fund changes too.
- 4. An is priced once a day at its NAV, after the close.
- 5. An is priced all day on the exchange. Market makers keep that price close to the value of what the fund holds.
Index fund or ETF?
Index fund
- No account needed. Buy from the fund house or an app.
- One price a day, the NAV.
- Easy to automate with a monthly SIP.
ETF
- Needs a account and a broker.
- Live prices all through market hours.
- Brokerage and a on every trade, and on a quiet the price can drift from what the fund holds.
Important terms
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| A mutual fund that copies an index | |
| Exchange-traded fund: an index copy you buy and sell on the exchange | |
| Mutual fund | A pool of many investors' money, invested by a fund house |
| NAV | Net asset value: what one unit of the fund is worth, worked out daily |
| Expense ratio | The yearly fee, taken as a percentage of what you hold |
| SIP | Systematic investment plan: a fixed amount invested automatically every month |
| Tracking difference | How far the fund's return fell short of the index's |
Why does it matter?
- Most actively managed large-cap funds in India have trailed their index over long periods, after their higher fees. Over those periods, simply matching the index finished ahead of most of them.
- Fees compound. A 1% difference a year is a very large difference over twenty years.
- It is the plainest version of "owning the market", and the benchmark every other choice is measured against.
What can change it?
- The index itself. When it swaps a member, the fund follows.
- The fee. Fund houses can change the expense ratio, and cheaper funds keep arriving.
- Trading in the . If few people are trading a particular , its price can sit away from its real value.
Common misconceptions
- "An cannot fall." It falls exactly as much as the index does.
- "A lower NAV is a cheaper fund." The NAV is just the price of one unit. What you pay yearly is the expense ratio.
- "An and an are the same thing." They copy the same index and are bought, priced and held differently.
- "Fifty companies means my money is evenly." The ten biggest carry well over half of NIFTY's weight.
What are the risks and limitations?
- You carry the whole market's fall. There is no manager deciding to step aside.
- Concentration. A few very large companies decide most of what the fund does.
- An with little trading can cost more to buy and sell than its expense ratio suggests.
Quick recap
- : copies an index, bought at the daily NAV, no needed.
- : copies an index, trades on the exchange like a share.
- Low yearly fee, and the return of the index, good years and bad.
- It will not beat the market, and that is the design.